My Journey to Stoicism (PIII)

“You become what you give your attention to.” – Epictetus

Exploring Socratic dialectics, fate, free will, and life's meaning on my Stoic journey (Part III).

This is part 3 of my 4 part series on ‘My Journey to Stoicism.’ Link to Part I

To better understand the Stoics, I started reading more on Socrates, who was a source of inspiration for the founder of Stoicism. Zeno founded Stoicism after reading Xenophon’s ‘Memorabilia’, a dialogue of Socrates. An interesting perspective I heard is to recognize that the founder of Stoicism was inspired by a student of Socrates who was a military leader. How might Stoicism have been different if Zeno had read Plato rather than Xenophon? 

Plato is our other best source of information on what Socrates taught. Socratic Dialectics can be summarized “finding truth often comes from dialogue (dia-logos).” One person makes a statement (the thesis), the other person makes strong arguments for the opposite (the anti-thesis), and some greater truth is often found between those two extremes (a synthesis). 

Dialectics. Some greater truth is found between two extremes: a synthesis. 

Is Fate predetermined or do we have free will? The Stoic position is “soft-determinism”. It’s something between those two extremes. It depends on what point of view you are taking (your internal conscious view or an external, historical point of view; see my Between Two Ravens blog ‘On Fate’)

This dialectic perspective on Truth is helpful, both for learning to understand other people who have different viewpoints, and coming to gain an understanding on the most difficult questions in life for yourself.

What is the meaning of life? Either it has a singular meaning or it is meaningless. Or maybe it has a different meaning for different people and at different life stages.

What is the nature of the human soul (the psyche)? It is a question Plato asked and his thinking had a profound influence on psychoanalysis. Does the soul exist or not exist? It cannot be observed externally, but it is something we can experience by looking within (subjectively).

Does God exist? Either God exists or does not exist. Or can you believe (have belief or faith) in something that cannot be observed objectively?

In Part IV I will discuss how studying Stoicism led me to asking questions where Jungian Psychology helped me to find answers.


Leave a Reply

David Alexander

New Mexico-based psychotherapist exploring Stoic Philosophy and Jungian psychology to understand human nature, aiming for self-discovery and empathy through integrated disciplines.

Get mentored by David Alexander

GET UPDATES FROM The Prosoche Project


David Alexander

What is Love? (P2)

Exploring the multifaceted concept of love, this article delves into the various dimensions of affection, from passionate desire to spiritual

Read More »
David Alexander

Love the Dog

Amid life’s challenges, the simple joys of arriving home, walking in the park, and nurturing unconditional love bind us to

Read More »